We know why you want them home
The stockings are hung, or the Menorah is out. The good dishes are out of the cabinet. And somewhere in all that holiday bustle, there’s a chair at the table you keep glancing at.
If someone you love is in treatment this season, you’ve probably already pictured them walking through the front door. Maybe you’ve rehearsed the phone call. Maybe they’ve asked you point-blank to bring them home. Wanting that isn’t a mistake. It’s love, pure, and simple.
It’s also okay if it hurts. Hannah Unruh, LCSW, LCDC, Alta Loma’s Director of Family Services, reminds families that wanting your loved ones home at Christmas is completely normal and there’s real grief in going without. Plenty of family members carry guilt, too. Could I have caught this sooner? Am I making them suffer by saying no? Alta Loma’s Clinical Director, Jessica Brodie, LCSW, LCDC hears those questions every year. Her answer is gentle and firm: “Just because you feel guilty does not make you a bad person. It makes you a human.”
Below, you’ll find what the research says about timing, how our team thinks about it, and ways to be together this season that protects the progress your loved one has worked so hard to make.
Why the holidays pull so hard
You’re not alone in feeling this emotional tug. In a 2024 American Psychiatric Association poll, 28% of Americans said they felt more stressed about the holidays than the year before. The top stressor? Grieving a loss or missing a loved one, named by 47% of people. Affording gifts (46%) and tricky family dynamics (35%) weren’t far behind.
For families of someone in treatment, that pull often shows up in a few familiar ways:
- Tradition and milestones. It’s the first Christmas since the diagnosis, or Grandma’s last one in the old house. Missing it feels unthinkable.
- The picture of them “alone.” It’s hard to imagine your person spending the holidays anywhere but home.
- Visible progress. “He sounds so much better on the phone!” That’s wonderful news. Still, steadiness inside a structured setting can look a lot like readiness for home when it isn’t quite there yet.
- Practical pressure. You’ve got time off work. The flights are booked. Insurance or cost worries are humming in the background.
- Their own requests. When your loved one asks to come home, the ask lands right in your heart. Those conversations are emotional and often very persuasive.
Here’s a question we invite families to sit with: Is this decision about my loved one’s health and safety, or about the image I’ve been holding of everyone together around the tree? Both are human. However, a loved one’s happiness can’t come at the expense of their health and safety. Choosing health now usually sets the stage for lasting happiness later. Choosing a happy moment now rarely leads to lasting health.
What the research says about timing
The first weeks home from treatment are the most fragile, in any month. One 2019 review of 34 studies in BMJ Open found suicide rates were highest in the first week after leaving care and stayed elevated through the first month. An earlier review in JAMA Psychiatry found the same pattern across the first three months. Data like this is exactly why we plan transitions so carefully.
Leaving early is linked to tougher outcomes. A review in Psychiatric Services found that people who left inpatient care against medical advice got less benefit from treatment. They also struggled more afterward and returned to the hospital sooner.
For dual-diagnosis clients, overdose risk spikes after leaving treatment. A Texas study of nearly 179,000 people found drug-related deaths peaked in the first 28 days after treatment ended. Risk ran higher after residential care. Completing treatment, on the other hand, was linked to lower risk. Here’s why: after a stretch without using, tolerance drops. A “normal” holiday drink or an old familiar dose can hit far harder than anyone expects.
You may have heard that suicides spike at Christmas. They don’t. CDC data reviewed by the Annenberg Public Policy Center shows December actually had the lowest daily suicide rate of any month in 2023. However, the weeks after the holidays tell a different story. Researchers in Austria found rates stayed low through Christmas and then peaked on New Year’s Day. Routines reset. Visitors go home. Support thins out. If a discharge lands mid-holiday, the most fragile weeks of recovery overlap with that post-holiday dip.
Holiday stress adds up. In a 2014 NAMI survey, 64% of people living with mental illness said the holidays make their conditions worse. Gatherings often mean alcohol on the table, old family roles, late nights, broken routines, and missed medication times. Each one can have consequences on its own. All at once, in someone’s first weeks home, they can be debilitating.
So, what does all this mean for your family? The holidays themselves aren’t the danger. The real risk comes from squeezing a fragile transition into the busiest, most unpredictable weeks of the year. Our clinical team will always give you an honest recommendation about timing. In the end, the choice is yours. However, when you work with our clinical team and follow their recommendations, we’re better able to set your loved one up for lasting success.
Your loved one won’t spend the holidays alone
At Alta Loma, we never want anyone sitting in treatment feeling forgotten on the holidays. Our chefs cook a big holiday meal at both Thanksgiving and Christmas. Clients decorate the tree together. And yes, we light a menorah, too.
For Stephanie Castro, CTRS, TRS/TXC, our Director of Recreation Therapy, this season is basically her team’s Super Bowl. They start planning more than a month ahead and build activities around what clients themselves say they enjoy. This year’s lineup includes:
- A Friendsgiving and karaoke day with an awards ceremony celebrating every client’s effort, from showing up to groups to being a great friend in the community.
- Holiday cards. Clients craft homemade cards and mail them to loved ones. Any extras go to a local nursing home, so clients get to give back and feel more connected to the community.
- A 12 Days of Christmas countdown, where each day features a different coping skill clients have said they love.
- Gratitude trees, stockings and a winter party on Christmas Eve. Stockings hold comforting, safe goodies like stress balls, fidgets and cozy socks.
- A tree-decorating contest and New Year’s vision boards to name goals and celebrate wins.
Just as important, Stephanie wants clients to have a say in how they celebrate and to make good memories during a season that could otherwise feel heavy. Years from now, they may remember the stocking full of comforting things, the vision board, and the cards they mailed home. “I want to make an imprint. I want to make an impact,” she says. Her hope is that families feel relief knowing their loved one is being met with thoughtfulness and care. Better yet, clients can carry these new traditions home and share them with loved ones.
Ways to stay connected this season
How you celebrate together depends on your loved one’s level of care and their treatment team’s approval. At The Ranch and Casa Esperanza, our family team sets up a 20-minute video call for each client on Christmas Day, or the days surrounding Christmas, depending on what works best scheduling-wise. Clients who celebrate a different holiday can call on that day instead. Once someone has been with us for 60 days, families may also work with the clinical team to plan a supervised two-hour visit on site, with food, games and gifts welcome and encouraged.
At The Villa and The Chalet, clients in their early adjustment period can enjoy a shorter family visit, which may happen off campus. After that, you’re welcome to spend the whole day together as long as your loved one is back by curfew. In our supportive living homes, the team may approve an overnight while you stay nearby. Occasionally, with careful planning, a trip home is possible too.
You can also start a new tradition from afar:
- Trade letters or “what I’m proud of” notes.
- Hang a recovery-milestone ornament on your tree.
- Open gifts together over video, or build a shared holiday playlist.
Finally, plan for the questions. Agree as a family on how you’ll answer relatives who ask, “Where’s Jake this year?” A simple, kind response protects your loved one’s privacy and your peace of mind.
When the time is right: step down, don’t jump
Home is always the goal. We just want your loved one to get there in a way that lasts. That’s why our care steps down gradually, from our primary programs to extended care and supportive living, rather than ending all at once.
How does the team know someone is ready for the next step? Our clinical teams look for signs like these:
- Showing up to groups and taking part
- Taking medications as prescribed and raising concerns with their psychiatrist
- Fewer symptoms and steady progress in therapy
- Getting along with peers and staff and working through conflicts
- No self-harm, suicidal thoughts or physical altercations for at least three weeks
- Handling daily routines like hygiene, sleep and a tidy room without reminders
- Knowing who to ask for what, whether that’s their therapist, a nurse or a coordinator
- A completed, reviewed safety plan
Nobody nails every item every day. These markers simply show steady progress.
When discharge does come into view, a good plan makes all the difference. Our teams ask for at least two weeks of notice, and ideally closer to a month. That runway lets the team:
- Hold a family meeting so you and your loved one can agree on boundaries and expectations.
- Book appointments before discharge day. You’ll know the first psychiatry and therapy dates ahead of time. Our team often recommends therapy, medication management, and a support group such as NAMI, AA, or an intensive outpatient program.
- Make medication continuity a plan. Sort out prescriptions, refills and who holds what.
- Write a safety and relapse plan together, with warning signs and who to call.
- Prepare the home. Remove or lock up alcohol, medications, and firearms. Then build a routine that protects sleep.
- Time it on purpose. A post-holiday step-down, around early to mid-January, often means outpatient providers are fully staffed, and household routines are back in rhythm.
The best gift might be a little more time
Not long ago, a young man left our program against medical advice and made his way home. His family faced an agonizing choice. They brought him back. At first, he resisted. Then something clicked and he started improving fast. In a recent session, his mom reflected, “This is the hardest thing I’ve ever done. And I’m so glad that we did it.” His parents now see a version of their son they weren’t sure they’d ever see again.
Waiting is hard. Waiting while the rest of the world sings carols about it being the most wonderful time of the year can feel even harder. Yet a quieter holiday this year can make room for many fuller ones ahead.
Whatever you decide, you’re not navigating it alone. Reach out to our team anytime with questions, worries or ideas for making this season special. We’re on your side and on your loved one’s side, too.
Looking for care for yourself or someone you love? Our admissions team is here to listen. Reach out to learn how Alta Loma can help and whether our program is the right fit.
If you or someone you love is in crisis, call or text 988
Sources:
FAQs:
Usually, yes. It depends on their level of care and their treatment team’s approval. At Alta Loma’s Ranch and Casa Esperanza, the family team sets up a 20-minute video call on or around Christmas Day. After 60 days in care, families can plan a supervised two-hour visit on site. Clients in step-down programs may get day visits, overnights or even a carefully planned trip home.
Yes. The first weeks home are the most fragile stretch of recovery, no matter the month. A 2019 BMJ Open review of 34 studies found suicide rates peaked in the first week after leaving care and stayed high through the first month. For people with substance use concerns, a Texas study found drug-related deaths peaked in the first 28 days after treatment ended.
No. That’s a common myth. CDC data reviewed by the Annenberg Public Policy Center shows December had the lowest daily suicide rate of any month in 2023. The weeks after the holidays tell a different story. Austrian researchers found rates stayed low through Christmas and then peaked on New Year’s Day. By then routines reset, visitors leave and support thins out.
Alta Loma asks for at least two weeks’ notice, ideally closer to a month. That runway gives the team time to hold a family meeting and book therapy and psychiatry appointments. It also covers a medication plan and a written safety and relapse plan. Early to mid-January is often a good time to transition, because outpatient providers are fully staffed again.
Leaving against medical advice (AMA) is linked to tougher outcomes. A review in Psychiatric Services found people who left inpatient care AMA got less benefit from treatment. They also struggled more afterward and went back to the hospital sooner. For dual-diagnosis clients, there’s another danger. Tolerance drops after time without using, so a familiar dose can hit much harder than expected.









